Pennsylvania vs. Florida: What Do the Numbers Say?
According to the FBI's 2024 data, Pennsylvania's violent crime rate was 246 per 100,000 residents. Florida's was 267. Property crime was nearly even: 1,435 in Pennsylvania vs. 1,420 in Florida.
But look at the deadliest crime. Florida's murder rate was 3.9 per 100,000, and Pennsylvania's was 5.0. That's about 28% higher in the Keystone State.
The gap shows up most in the big cities. Philadelphia, known for progressive prosecution and bail reform, recorded 222 homicides in 2025. That's its lowest total since 1966, but still far above Florida's big metros. All of Miami-Dade County, with more people than Philadelphia, recorded 78 homicides, down 26% from the year before.
Florida has stuck with tough-on-crime prosecution and strict bail policies. Philadelphia took the opposite approach, and its homicide totals hit record highs before falling.
So, which approach keeps families safer: Florida's or Philadelphia's?
