Louisiana Judge Orders Kalshi, Polymarket and Other Prediction Markets to Stop Taking Trades in the State
Louisiana has become one of the main battlegrounds in the national fight over prediction markets after a state judge ordered some of the industry’s biggest names to stop offering their event contracts to people in the state.
Attorney General Liz Murrill filed suit Thursday against Kalshi, Polymarket, Robinhood and other companies, accusing them of ignoring and undermining Louisiana’s gambling laws. That same afternoon, Judge Jeffrey Johnson in Tangipahoa Parish issued a temporary restraining order requiring the companies to halt those markets in Louisiana. According to The Advocate, the order applies only to the prediction-market side of businesses such as Robinhood and the cryptocurrency exchange Coinbase. Robinhood halted those contracts in Louisiana on Thursday.
“It’s not complicated: if you aren’t a licensed gaming operator, you aren’t legal,” Murrill said after the ruling.
Kalshi pushed back Friday with a notice to Louisiana users on its website, saying the state had acted “without a hearing, notice, or due process.” The Advocate reported it was unclear whether Kalshi would comply, and users were still able to place money on event contracts Friday. Two weeks earlier, Kalshi had sued Murrill and other state officials in federal court, arguing that Louisiana has no authority to regulate the industry. The company asked that court for its own restraining order Thursday; no ruling had been issued as of Friday.
At the heart of the dispute is a simple question: are these contracts investments or bets? Prediction-market companies say they offer financial products that can be used to hedge risk, which would put them under the federal Commodity Futures Trading Commission rather than state regulators. Murrill and officials in more than a dozen other states argue that much of the trading is on sports and other outcomes that look a lot like traditional wagers. Murrill also argues the companies are avoiding the taxes Louisiana imposes on sports betting, which is legal only in parishes whose voters approved it.
Daniel Wallach, a Miami-based attorney who focuses on sports-betting law, told The Advocate that naming the whole industry in a single state-court lawsuit sidestepped the “whack-a-mole problem” other states have faced. He said Louisiana is now one of just four states with injunctions in place, and that the order could keep the companies out of the state while Kalshi’s federal case plays out, which he said could take a year or longer.
Source: The Advocate
Photo: Chrismiceli / Wikimedia Commons, CC0 (Louisiana State Capitol in Baton Rouge, 2012 file photo; cropped and credit added)
